Contested Puberty: Judicial Discretion, Moral Regulation, and the Persistence of Child Marriage in Indonesia

Y Sonafist; Azhar; Syukrawati; Nurjanah Nurjanah; Wail Abouabaid

doi:10.66325/nusantaralaw.v5i2.278

Authors

Y Sonafist Institut Agama Islam Negeri Kerinci, Indonesia
Azhar Institut Agama Islam Negeri Kerinci, Indonesia
Syukrawati Institut Agama Islam Negeri Kerinci, Indonesia
Nurjanah Nurjanah Universitas Negeri Padang, Indonesia
Wail Abouabaid College of Law-Faculty Adjunct, Abu Dhabi University, United Arab Emirates

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.66325/nusantaralaw.v5i2.278

Keywords:

Child Marriage; Judicial Discretion; Marriage Dispensation; Legal Pluralism.

Abstract

The 2019 revision of Indonesia's Marriage Law raised the minimum marriage age to 19, yet produced a striking paradox: rather than reducing child marriage, it precipitated a sharp increase in marriage dispensation applications in religious courts. This article argues that the reform displaced the site of legitimation for child marriage—shifting authorization from administrative registration to judicial approval through dispensation mechanisms—revealing not merely a failure of legal implementation, but a deeper process through which the state and judiciary actively reproduce the legal boundaries of adulthood and child protection. Drawing on a socio-legal framework, this study employs critical discourse analysis of two complementary sites: the normative constructions embedded in the Marriage Law—particularly the ambiguous phrase "urgent reasons"—and the judicial reasoning inscribed in religious court dispensation decisions. An empirical examination of trends in national post-reform dispensation supplements this dual-object analysis. Together, these methods trace a discursive struggle between two competing normative orders: state-led discourses of child protection and gender equality on one side, and moral-religious discourses mobilized by judges in interpreting puberty, social readiness, and family honor on the other. The findings reveal that broad judicial discretion functions as an institutional mechanism through which child marriage continues to obtain legal legitimacy despite the formally elevated minimum age, which this article terms the "judicial backdoor." Judges routinely authorize dispensations by invoking moral-religious considerations such as pregnancy, the imperative to prevent zina, and avoidance of social stigma, thereby subordinating child rights protections to communal moral norms. Without standardized criteria for "compelling grounds" and a child rights-based evaluative framework, legal reform risks functioning as a symbolic gesture that leaves the patriarchal structures underpinning child marriage substantively intact. This article contributes to broader debates on legal pluralism, judicial discretion, and the challenges of implementing gender-sensitive reform in socio-religious contexts.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abdul Rahim, Abdul Rahim, and others, 'Minimum Marriage Age in the Compilation of Islamic Law: A Progressive Ijtihad Based on Maslahah Fardiyyah and 'A'Iliyyah', Jurnal Hukum Islam, 23.2 (2025), pp. 381–410, doi:10.28918/jhi.v23i2.02

Abdullah, Zaitun, and Putri Ayu Maharani, 'Unveiling the Enigma: Exploring Regulated Marriage Age Limits from the Lens of Maslahah Mursalah', Nurani: Jurnal Kajian Syari'ah Dan Masyarakat, 24.1 (2024), pp. 119–138, doi:10.19109/nurani.v24i1.22370

Amin, Ibnu, and others, 'The Concept of Baligh Perspective of Fiqh and Positive Law', Al-Istinbath : Jurnal Hukum Islam, 7.2 (2022), p. 455, doi:10.29240/jhi.v7i2.5268

Andar Yuni, Lilik, 'Analysis of The Emergency Reasons in The Application of Marriage Dispensation at The Tenggarong Religious Court', Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Dan Hukum Islam, 5.2 (2021), p. 976, doi:10.22373/sjhk.v5i2.9135

Antori, Mulyadi, Sukiati Sukiati, and Imam Yazid, 'Resolving Marriage Dispensation Cases for Pregnant Women Due to Adultery as Urgent Grounds: An Analysis of Practices in the Simalungun Religious Court', Jurnal Ilmiah Mizani: Wacana Hukum, Ekonomi Dan Keagamaan, 11.2 (2024), p. 300, doi:10.29300/mzn.v11i2.5117

Asman, Asman, 'family Law Reform In Indonesia: Analysis Of Age Of Adulthood In Marriage', Journal of Shariah Law Research, 9.1 (2024), pp. 1–26, doi:10.22452/jslr.vol9no1.1

Asmuni, Asmuni, and Rezha Nur Adikara Rezha Nur Adikara, 'Application of Very Urgent Criteria in The Marriage Dispensation Norms for the Protection of Children: Analysis of Jasser Auda's Theory', Jurnal Hukum Islam, 22.1 (2024), pp. 25–56, doi:10.28918/jhi_v22i1_2

Astari, Adella, and Sa'adatul Maghfira, 'Legal Assessment Of Marriage Dispensation Applications: Insights From The Painan Religious Court', Al Ushuliy: Jurnal Mahasiswa Syariah Dan Hukum, 4.1 (2025), pp. 61–73, doi:10.31958/alushuliy.v4i1.15715

Bukido, Rosdalina, and others, 'Muslim Society's Response to the New Rule of Marriage Age', Al-Istinbath: Jurnal Hukum Islam, 8.1 May (2023), p. 135, doi:10.29240/jhi.v8i1.5521

——, 'Reception of Marriage Age Limit in Marriage Law in Indonesia', Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Dan Hukum Islam, 7.1 (2023), p. 146, doi:10.22373/sjhk.v7i1.15245

‘Cegah Pernikahan Di Bawah Umur Demi Kualitas Generasi Penerus Yang Lebih Baik’, Mpr.Go.Id, 2023 <https://mpr.go.id/berita/Cegah-Pernikahan-di-Bawah-Umur-demi-Kualitas-Generasi-Penerus-yang-Lebih-Baik>

Dakhoir, Ahmad, and Sri Lumatus Sa'adah, 'Meta-Juridical Analysis on the Legal Arguments beyond Changes in Indonesian's Marriage Age Rule', AL-IHKAM: Jurnal Hukum & Pranata Sosial, 18.1 (2023), pp. 80–101, doi:10.19105/al-lhkam.v18i1.7162

Dewi, Anak Agung Istri Ari Atu, and others, 'The Role of Human Rights and Customary Law to Prevent Early Childhood Marriage in Indonesia', Sriwijaya Law Review, 6.2 (2022), pp. 268–285, doi:10.28946/slrev.Vol6.Iss2.1885.pp268-285

Elimartati, and others, 'From Custodians to Bystanders : Tigo Tungku Sajarangan' s Responses to Unregistered Marriages Practices in Minangkabau', Al-Ahwal: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Islamal, 18.1 (2025), pp. 47–64, doi:10.14421/ahwal.2025.18203

Elnakib, Shatha, and others, 'Understanding the Impacts of Child Marriage on the Health and Well-Being of Adolescent Girls and Young Women Residing in Urban Areas in Egypt', Reproductive Health, 19.1 (2022), p. 8, doi:10.1186/s12978-021-01315-4

Fadhli, Ashabul, and others, 'Out-of-Court Assistance Based on the Principle of the Best Interests of the Child: Study on Examination Process of Marriage Dispensation Cases', JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 23.1 (2024), p. 67, doi:10.31958/juris.v23i1.10281

Fadhli, Ashabul, and Arifki Budia Warman, '“Alasan Khawatir” Pada Penetapan Hukum Dispensasi Kawin Di Pengadilan Agama Batusangkar “Reasons for Concern” on Marriage Dispensation Decisions in Batusangkar Religious Court’, Al-Ahwal, 14.2 (2021), pp. 146–158, doi:10.14421/ahwal.2021.14203

Faiz, Muhammad Fauzinudin, Zezen Zainul Ali, and Muhammad Taufiq, ‘Underage Widows and Widowers before the Law: Problem, Contestation and Legal Certainty in Marriage Dispensation’, JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 22.2 (2023), p. 223, doi:10.31958/juris.v22i2.9097

Fatarib, Husnul, and others, ‘Progressive Legal Reasoning in Contemporary Islamic Legal Reform: Negotiating the Maqāṣid and Hermeneutic Approaches’, JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 24.2 (2025), pp. 277–94, doi:10.31958/juris.v24i2.16123

Fausi, Achmad, and Asmuni Asmuni, ‘Determination of the Minimum Age Limit for Marriage: Balancing Legal Supremacy and the Objectives of Sharia in Indonesian Marriage Law’, Mazahib, 23.1 (2024), pp. 117–154, doi:10.21093/mj.v23i1.7611

Foucault, Michel, Power/Knowledge: Wacana Kuasa/Pengetahuan, ed. by Yudi Santosa (Bentang Budaya, 2002)

Hanapi, Agustin, Sarina Aini, and Cut Endang Puspa Sari, ‘Bridging Fiqh and Positive Law: A New Paradigm for Child Legality and the Best Interest of the Child in Indonesia’, Juris: Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah, 23.2 (2024), pp. 293–308, doi:10.31958/juris.v23i2.10712

Hasudungan, Anju Nofarof, ‘Increasing Child Marriage in Indonesia during the Covid-19 Pandemic: What Causes It?’, Salus Cultura: Jurnal Pembangunan Manusia Dan Kebudayaan, 2.2 (2022), pp. 151–161, doi:10.55480/saluscultura.v2i2.62

Hidayat, Syahrudin, Abdul Ghofur, and Ummul Baroroh, ‘The Norm of Marriage Age Limit and Cultural Contestation of Child Marriage Law in Rural Communities’, Jurnal Hukum Islam, 21.1 (2023), pp. 55–82, doi:10.28918/jhi_v21i1_03

Hidayati, Rahmi, and others, ‘Dynamics of Child Marriage in Suku Anak Dalam Community’, Justicia Islamica, 20.2 (2023), pp. 261–280, doi:10.21154/justicia.v20i2.5975

Indra, Gandi Liyorba, M. Yasin Al Arif, and Abdul Qodir Zaelani, ‘The Ideal Age For Marriage in The Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI) and Psychology’, Al-’Adalah, 20.1 (2023), p. 1, doi:10.24042/adalah.v20i1.11598

Iwan, and others, ‘Reconceptualizing the Marriage Age Limit in Indonesia: Efforts to Strengthen Family Resilience in North Sumatra’, Al-Manahij: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam, 18.1 (2024), pp. 161–178, doi:10.24090/mnh.v18i1.11090

Jayani, Dwi Hadya, ‘Dispensasi Perkawinan Anak Meningkat 3 Kali Lipat Pada 2020’, Databoks, 2021

Julianto, Very, and others, ‘Judges’ Perspectives on Changes in the Legal Minimum Age at Marriage in Indonesia’, Journal of Family Studies, 31.1 (2025), pp. 94–117, doi:10.1080/13229400.2024.2419870

Kafidhoh, Siti, and others, ‘Dynamics Of Legal Politics Regarding Marriage Age Limits In Indonesia: Between Religious Norms And Social Change’, Jurnal Hukum Islam, 22.2 (2024), pp. 405–436, doi:10.28918/jhi.v22i2.06

Liem, Andrian, and others, ‘Factors Associated with Child Marriage during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Indonesia’, Contemporary Islam, 18.3 (2024), pp. 457–478, doi:10.1007/s11562-023-00545-6

M. Hendri Agustiawan, and Nazhifatum Mutahhirah, ‘Socio-Legal Analysis of Early Marriage Phenomenon during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Jombang Regency’, Asketik, 7.1 (2023), pp. 89–100, doi:10.30762/asketik.v7i1.962

Mansari, Mansari, and others, ‘Concretizationof Urgent Reason And Sufficientevidence In Providing Marriage Dispensation For Children By The Judge’, Nurani: Jurnal Kajian Syari’ah Dan Masyarakat, 20.2 (2020), pp. 195–206, doi:10.19109/nurani.v20i2.5898

Miqat, Nurul, and others, ‘The Development of Indonesian Marriage Law in Contemporary Era’, De Jure: Jurnal Hukum Dan Syar’iah, 15.1 (2023), pp. 54–66, doi:10.18860/j-fsh.v15i1.17461

Mufarida, Binti, ‘4 Provinsi Ini Catatkan Angka Dispensasi Nikah Tertinggi Di Indonesia’, Sindonews. Com, 2023

Mursyid, Salma, and Nasruddin Yusuf, ‘Changes in Marriage Age Limits and Marriage Dispensations: A Study of Causes and Impacts on the Religious Courts in North Sulawesi’, Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Dan Hukum Islam, 6.2 (2022), p. 975, doi:10.22373/sjhk.v6i2.12439

Nabilah, Wardatun, and others, ‘Between Protection and Permissiveness: A Fiqh Siyasah Reexamination of Marriage Dispensation in Indonesia’, JURIS (Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah), 24.1 (2025), p. 137, doi:10.31958/juris.v24i1.11882

Nabilah, Wardatun, Dewi Putri, and Deri Rizal, ‘Jasser Auda’s System Approach in The Rules of Marriage Dispensation in Indonesia (Review of Maqashid Syariah)’, The Indonesian Journal of Islamic Law and Civil Law, 5.2 (2024), pp. 265–281

Naimah, Farida Ulvi, and others, ‘Internalization of Local Traditions in Child Marriage from the Perspective of Maqasid Al-Usrah’, El-Mashlahah, 14.2 (2024), pp. 237–258, doi:10.23971/el-mashlahah.v14i2.7942

Novitasari, Ane Fany, Thohir Luth, and Nur Chanifah, ‘The Maturity in Marriage Law’, Russian Law Journal, 11.2 (2023), pp. 553–559

Octavia, Nurul Aini, Wardatun Nabilah, and Martia Lestari, ‘Deviation Of Marriage Age Issues in Indonesia (Integration Review of Maqashid Sharia and Positive Law)’, Istinbath : Jurnal Hukum, 20.02 (2023), pp. 1–20, doi:10.32332/istinbath.v20i02.10009

Purnomo, Agus, and others, ‘Dimensions of Maqāṣid Al-Sharī‘Ah and Human Rights in the Constitutional Court’s Decision on Marriage Age Difference in Indonesia’, Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Dan Hukum Islam, 7.3 (2023), p. 1397, doi:10.22373/sjhk.v7i3.13283

Rahmi, Nailur, Arifki Budia Warman, and Amri Effendi, ‘Building Legal Compliance: A Study on the Practice of Unregistered Marriages in Tanjung Raya Subdistrict, Agam Regency, West Sumatra, Indonesia’, Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Dan Hukum Islam, 9.1 (2025), pp. 416–437, doi:10.22373/sjhk.v9i1.28306

Raj, Anita, ‘When the Mother Is a Child: The Impact of Child Marriage on the Health and Human Rights of Girls’, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 95.11 (2010), pp. 931–935, doi:10.1136/adc.2009.178707

Rizki, Darlin, Frina Oktalita, and Ali Sodiqin, ‘Maqasid Sharia Perspective in Changes the Marriage Age Limits for Women According to Law Number 16 of 2019’, Al-Istinbath : Jurnal Hukum Islam, 7.2 (2022), p. 501, doi:10.29240/jhi.v7i2.4016

Rohman, Taufiqur, and others, ‘Preventing Violations of Religious and Social Norms: Judicial Interpretation of “Urgent Reasons” in Marriage Dispensation at the Wonosari Religious Court, Indonesia’, Journal of Islamic Law, 4.2 (2023), pp. 218–236, doi:10.24260/jil.v4i2.1535

Rosyadi, Imron, Helmy Ziaul Fuad, and Ashlaha Baladina Zaimuddin, ‘Criminalization of Unregistered Marriage in Indonesia: A Legal System Analysis Based on Friedman’s Theory’, Al-’Adalah, 22.1 (2025), pp. 147–80, doi:10.24042/adalah.v221.22779

Sakirman, Sakirman, and Yulia Rizki Amanda, ‘Effectiveness of Marriage Age Limit According to Law Number 16 of 2019 in East Lampung’, MILRev : Metro Islamic Law Review, 1.2 (2022), p. 164, doi:10.32332/milrev.v1i2.6206

Sari, May Nela, and others, ‘Public’s Legal Awareness on Marriage Age Limit’, Jurnal Integrasi Ilmu Syariah (Jisrah), 5.1 (2024), pp. 75–82, doi:10.31958/jisrah.v5i1.12141

Sarip, Sarip, and others, ‘Legal Dialectics: Age Limits for Marriage and Political Rights in Indonesia’, Jurnal Hukum Novelty, 13.1 (2022), p. 49, doi:10.26555/novelty.v13i1.a19018

Sulaeman, Otong, and others, ‘Negotiating Gender Justice in Minangkabau Marital Disputes: Between Adat, Islamic, and State Law’, Juris: Jurnal Ilmiah Syariah, 24.1 (2025), pp. 39–49, doi:10.31958/juris.v24i1.11848

Sulistyorini, Yuly, Arief Wibowo, and Diah Indriani, ‘The Increasing Rate of Marriages and Premarital Pregnancies in Adolescents during the Transitional Period of Changes to the Marriage Law’, Journal of Public Health in Africa, 14.2 (2023), p. 6, doi:10.4081/jphia.2023.2553

Suryani, Irma, and others, ‘Between Culture and Safety: The Paradox of Protecting Domestic Violence Victims in Mediation at the Batusangkar Religious Court, Indonesia’, Nusantara: Journal of Law Studies, 5.1 (2026), pp. 331–358, doi:10.66325/nusantaralaw.v5i1.168

——, ‘The Possibility of Talaq Performers Criminalization in Indonesia: An Essential Lesson from India’, Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 4.3 (2024), pp. 593–620, doi:10.53955/jhcls.v4i3.282

Syufa’at, Syufa’at, ‘Marriage Dispensation in Underage Marriage: A Case Study at the Purwokerto Religious Court’, Al-Manahij: Jurnal Kajian Hukum Islam, 16.1 (2022), pp. 91–102, doi:10.24090/mnh.v16i1.4229

Turnip, Ibnu Radwan Siddik, Zainul Fuad, and Nurhayati Nurhayati, ‘The Current Development of Marriage Age Provisions in Indonesia and Malaysia: A Socio-Historical Approach’, Jurnal Ilmiah Al-Syir’ah, 20.1 (2022), p. 105, doi:10.30984/jis.v20i1.1813

Utami, Ria Anggraeni, and others, ‘Rethinking Early Marriages in Indonesia: Advocating for Reform to Tackle Domestic Conflict, Violence, and Rights Infringements’, Indonesian Journal of Advocacy and Legal Services, 5.1 (2023), pp. 35–64, doi:10.15294/ijals.v5i1.66569

Warman, Arifki Budia, and others, ‘From Communal to Individual: Shifting Authorities of Family Dispute Resolution in Minangkabau Society’, Ijtihad : Jurnal Wacana Hukum Islam Dan Kemanusiaan, 23.2 (2023), pp. 161–184, doi:10.18326/ijtihad.v23i2.161-184

——, ‘Perpetuating Women’s Subordination: Husband-Wife Relation in Pop Fiqh Literature’, Al-Ahwal: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Islam, 16.2 (2023), p. 259, doi:10.14421/ahwal.2023.16204

——, ‘Reforming Marriage Registration Policies in Malaysia and Indonesia’, Bestuur, 11.1 (2023), pp. 61–74, doi:10.20961/bestuur.v11i1.66320